Deciding to cover your tank or not is not an easy decision. Here are the arguments for and against having a cover. If you choose to have a cover, you’ll then have the choice of a glass lid, a screen, or a wood canopy.

Open Top

Open-top aquariums are growing in popularity—especially since rimless aquariums have become more widely available. Here are the pros and cons for having an open top
Pros
  • Easy entry for maintenance
  • No lid to clean
  • Plenty of evaporative cooling
  • Plenty of gas exchange
  • Excellent top down viewing
  • Allows for fun aquascapes with plants or decorations coming out of the water.
Cons
  • No protection against jumping fish
  • Increased evaporation
  • Increased room humidity
  • Poor heat retention

Glass Lids

Glass lids are the most common kind of aquarium lid. Most glass lids will sit inside a shelf built into an aquarium rim and have a hinge in the middle, as well as a cut away portion in the back of the lid for routing equipment wires and hoses.
Pros
  • Reduced evaporation
  • Reduced home humidity
  • Protection for jumping fish
  • Excellent heat retention
Cons
  • Difficult to enter the aquarium
  • Extremely difficult to clean
  • Reduced light penetration
  • Low gas exchange
  • Poor evaporative cooling

Screen Lids

Screen lids have become more popular as aquarists search for a way of preventing jumping fish while reducing the headaches that come from glass lids. Screen lids are usually a DIY project using window screen.
Pros
  • Protection for jumping fish
  • Plenty of gas exchange
  • Plenty evaporative cooling
Cons
  • Difficult to enter
  • Some minimal maintenance
  • Un-attractive-looking
  • Increased evaporation
  • Increased room humidity
  • Poor heat retention
  • Reduced light penetration (not as extreme as with glass.)

Wood Canopies

Wood Canopies were once very popular, but they now are only seen on large professionally installed aquariums. Wood canopies do not cover the surface of the aquarium but instead they form a wood shell around the top off the aquarium. This design can be used in conjunction with screen or glass lids or without.

Pros
  • Moderately easy for maintenance
  • No lid or screen to clean
  • No light spill into the room
  • Plenty of gas exchange
  • Plenty of evaporative cooling
  • Good protection against most jumping fish
  • Matches home furniture
  • Hides all lighting and equipment above the aquarium
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Increased evaporation
  • Increased room humidity
  • Poor heat retention
  • Some extra difficulty entering the aquarium.
  • No top-down view